Skip to main content

tv   Erin Burnett Out Front  CNN  January 28, 2013 4:00pm-5:00pm PST

4:00 pm
however many people were in the car, that's how many burgers they got. everyone in the hearse got a whopper jr., including the deceased. >> he would be thrilled, no doubt. >> after all, 15 minutes before he died, he was on the phone from the hospital joking with his daughter linda, asking her to bring him a burger, and she did. brought it to him here at prospect hill cemetery. the family had always tried to get him to eat healthier. but no more nagging, as linda laid the bag on the casket to be buried with him. what was that like? she cried. >> i remember thinking, dad, this is the first time i can do this is say okay, you can finally have your burger. >> reporter: a burger to go. jeanne moos, cnn, new york. >> whopper jr. little whopper. >> i will tell you, watching that, i'm really hungry now. i know that's bad for me.
4:01 pm
>> are you going to stauf off? >> no, no whoppers. >> that's it for us. thank you very much for watching. you can always follow what's going on here in "the situation room." you can go to twitter @wo twitter @wolfblitzer. you can follow kate, you can follow me. that's it for us. "erin burnett outfront" starts right now. "outfront" next, cooperation in washington. no, really, this is not a joke tonight. republicans and democrats coming together with a major bipartisan move. this is a major deal, and the fight may be coming. plus, president obama called hillary clinton one of the finest secretaries of state in american history. but guess what? not everybody thinks that's true. and later in the show, a follow up to last week's "outfront" investigation. a catholic hospital says life begins at birth, not conception. let's go "outfront."
4:02 pm
good evening. everyone. i'm erin burnett. happy monday. "outfront" tonight, bigs are flying. tonight, there is bipartisan efforts. pigs are flying, and it's a gorgeous sight. they thought they had an ice storm, but it's really pigs. what has caused them to take to the sky, you ask? immigration. a gang of senators unveiled a new immigration reform plan today, and this is pretty amazing. you have marco rubio on the same page as chuck schumer. yes, we told you pigs are in the air, and senator schumer has high hopes for this proposal. >> we believe this will be the year congress finally gets it done. the politics on this issue have been turned upside down. for the first time ever, there's more political risk in opposing immigration reform than in supporting it.
4:03 pm
>> but like everything else in washington, not everyone is on board. take republican senator mike lee. he quickly issued this statement in opposition to the gang's plan. here's what he said. reforms to our complexy and dysfunctional immigration system should not in any way favor those who came here illegally over the millions of applicants who seek to come here lawfully. the problem is without reform, there are 11 million people who are undocumented who are living in this country right now, and you can't just support them all. that's why everyone has hit a big wall until the pigs started flying today. miguel marquez spoke to some young people today, and here are their stories. this issue is very personal. >> three young latinos, they look, sound, and say they feel like americans. they're not. >> i identify myself with the american culture, but at the same time, the american society is like, no, you're not a part of us. >> rolando was brought here as a 7-year-old, wants to be a journalist. he was arrested in 2011.
4:04 pm
protesting legislation here that would limit access to a college education. he wants a clear path to citizenship. >> hopefully the obama administration does something different this time. he promised something in the first days of his administration. he failed. >> it sounds like you don't trust any politician. >> i honestly don't. >> this woman, her father a mechanic, her mother, a hairstylist, wants to be a lawyer. brought here as a 10-year-old, she's now qualified for the deferred action program. it allows students brought here as kids to apply for temporary legal status. 1.8 like her could be eligible. you're taken care of? >> yes, i'm taken care of. >> is your family? >> my parents are not. that's one of the things that scares me the most. >> jesus wants to be a doctor, brought here as an 11-year-old. he's now applying for deferred
4:05 pm
action but feels trapped between two worlds. >> it's amazing to see that, you know, they're willing to help us now because all my life, i have been here. not knowing what's going to be in my future, not knowing where i'm going to go. >> three kids wanting a piece of the american dream, all three watching, hoping that dream becomes reality. miguel marquez, cnn, savannah, georgia. >> tom tancredo is a former congressman from colorado, maria car done ais a contributor for us. representative tancredo, john mccain is part of this bipartisan drupe. like i said, a lot of people together you wouldn't expect to be standing together. but here's what he said about why republicans have to do this deal and do this deal now. >> elections. elections. the republican party is losing the support of our hispanic citizens. and we realize that there are many issues in which we think we
4:06 pm
are in agreement with our hispanic citizens, but this is a preeminent issue for those citizens. >> obviously, when you look at the election last time, president obama got 71% of the latino vote. mitt romney, 27%. is john mccain right? >> no, he really isn't. he's no more right this time than he was back in, what, '87, when he and another gang tried to put together a very similar bill. he and a member of that time of it was called the mccain-kennedy bill. very similar in every respect to what i have seen so far. i must admit i haven't seen the whole thing. from what i heard about it, very similar. at any rate, it's the same rhetoric, and it's just as wrong today as it was then. the reason, i mean, this is amazing, honestly. somehow, republicans, many republicans, mccain being one of them, have been led to believe that all we have to do as republicans is soften the stance on immigration, and we will begin to erode the democrat base
4:07 pm
that exists in the hispanic community. certainly, there is nothing to prove that. honestly, nothing, not one shred of evidence. not one poll ever taken shows hispanics saying, yeah, that's it. hispanics vote for democrats for exactly the same reason that other people vote for democrats. they want bigger government. nothing to do with immigration. >> i want to get maria's response. in a word, what is your problem with it as you perceive it? do you think the 11 million people here, there should be no path to citizenship? >> why would you give -- the most important, the most valuable thing we hand out to people who come here legally, that is citizenship, why would you do this to them? why would you be so unfair as to say, we're going to take that one thing, the best thing we give you for doing it the right way, and give it to people who did not do it the right way. it is not fair. >> maria, let me ask you a question about what the president is actually going to
4:08 pm
do about this and let me get this -- i want to play a sound bite for you. this is what democratic representative luis gutierrez told cnn today about what the president is going to do on immigration. >> the important thing on friday's meeting is that the president said he's going to make this his top priority, his number one priority. >> july 8, 2008, the president of the united states speaking to the league of latin american citizens. july 8, 2008, here he is on immigration. >> i will make it a top priority in my first year as president. >> trust him this time? >> i do, erin. and for a couple reasons. first of all, i think the president knows who he owes in large part his re-election. that is to the 71% of latinos who got him re-elected. the second thing is let's thing back to july of 2008. that was way before the economy went into freefall, so he had a couple other priorities he had to deal with when he first came into office. and the third thing, erin, is that this president wants this
4:09 pm
as his legacy. and he has said that he wants it to be a priority, even during the re-electiore-election, he tt this, so he knows that now he has a debt to pay. the republicans need to do this as a necessity, and with all due respect to the congressman, this is absolutely an issue of electoral survival for the republican party. the congressman is right that this isn't the only thing that republicans need to soften up their tone on, but if this isn't something they get done for the latino community, they're not going to listen to them on anything else. >> congressman, here is my problem intellec chatually from where you're coming from. and this is a complicated issue, but i don't understand. these people are already here. you're not going to be able to pick them up and move them out. that's not practical. so if you start from that point of view, how are you ever going to get a deal? >> if i could give you a very simple and i think incredibly efficient way of dealing with this issue, one that does not
4:10 pm
require rounding people up or anything else of that nature. but nonetheless, would certainly solve the biggest part of the problem. if i could give that to you, would you at least agree with me there is an alternative? and here is what i'm suggesting and have been suggesting for yours. it's something called e-verify. if you mandate e-verify for every employer in this country, you're doing a couple things. your doing a big, big favor for people who are here legally and can't get work. you're doing a big favor for immigrants who are here legally and can't get work, and you are of course dealing with this issue in the most humane issue possible. if you come the right way, you get the job. if your social security number is not right, you can't. you know, you have to go home. you'll have to take care of this yourself. they will self-deport, but because that is the easiest and certainly the most efficient way of dealing with it, we will never use it, but it's the best
4:11 pm
way, and it doesn't require rounding people up. >> i have to leave it there. thanks very much to both of you. interesting when you take that and you put it next to those kids miguel marquez spoke to, a tough issue and certainly not black and white. still to come, new developments in a story we covered last week. plus, iran launches its space program's first manned rocket. planet of the apes on its way. and why at least one former administration official disagreed with the president when he says this. >> i think hillary will go down as one of the finest secretary of states we've had. or that printing in color had to cost a fortune. nobody said an all-in-one had to be bulky. or that you had to print from your desk. at least, nobody said it to us. introducing the business smart inkjet all-in-one series
4:12 pm
from brother. easy to use. it's the ultimate combination of speed, small size, and low-cost printing. ♪ let's face it. everyone has their own way of doing things. at university of phoenix we know learning is no different. so we offer personalized tools and support, that let our students tackle the challenge of going back to school, like they do anything else... their way. see lioutdoors, or in.ight. transitions® lenses automatically filter just the right amount of light. so you see everything the way it's meant to be seen. maybe even a little better. visit your eyecare professional today
4:13 pm
to ask about our newest lenses, transitions vantage and transitions xtractive lenses. experience life well lit. ask which transitions adaptive lens is best for you. time can ofbe...well...taxing. so right now we'll give you... ...$10 off any turbo tax deluxe level software or higher! find thousands of big deals now... officemax. [ male announcer ] make your escape... twice as rewarding. earn double points or double miles on all your hotel stays through march thirty first. sign up now at on all your hotel stays through march thirty first. a hybrid? most are just no fun to drive. now, here's one that will make you feel alive. meet the five-passenger ford c-max hybrid. c-max says ha. c-max says wheeee. which is what you get, don't you see? cause c-max has lots more horsepower than prius v,
4:14 pm
a hybrid that c-max also bests in mpg. say hi to the all-new 47 combined mpg c-max hybrid. our second story "outfront," transformational or overrated? which word better describes the legacy of hillary rodham clinton as secretary of state? president obama thinks the first option is what people think. >> i think hillary will go down as one of the finest secretaries of states we've had. >> not everyone agrees. a former official tells the los angeles times, it's tough to see what has happened in world politics over the last four years that wouldn't have happened without her, so it's hard to see how she gets into the category of truly great, transformational secretaries. and all of the pete who were
4:15 pm
critical spoke as unnamed former officials. people who were complementary were willing to go by name. peter brooks, assistant secretary of defense in the bush administration, ann marie slaughter worked for secretary clinton. great to have both of you. peter, what do you think? we saw this article today in the "los angeles times." i have not seen many articles questioning at all the tenure of secretary clinton. this was the first. >> i'm not a diplomatic historian, but i think some of the fawning has been over the top. we saw this at her hearing over benghazi. we saw this, you know, i think, when she also introduced john kerry. i think you have to -- it's too early to say in terms of a legacy, but i think if you look at the record, there are a lot of problems that happened during her tenure. i would say things like syria, the lack of progress on iran, north korea, the russian relationship. you can go on and on and on. it's fair to say this is a very tough job, and each secretary of
4:16 pm
state gets a different set of circumstances they have to deal with, so it's very difficult to compare them. >> ann marie, what is your point of view? maybe this comes from her approval rating is something anybody on the planet, a celebrity would be happy to have, right? but it has become sort of the untouchable thing to say, you know what? maybe she wasn't the best ever. maybe she wasn't perfect? >> i don't know if she was the best ever. but she was fabulous. she restored our standing in the world, and she has put diplomacy back out front. right? we're now once again leading diplomatically. she's put together coalitions, you know, against north korea, against iran. i really think she has been fabulous. look at her boss thinks so. i'm not sure what more you need from that. >> let me throw out a few of the things that have happens. the israeli/arab conflict, she hasn't resolved that but no one
4:17 pm
else has. north korea, obviously threatening the united states as recently as last week and testing more missiles, then you have benghazi, the attack on the hostages in algeria, and now the mali situation. some of these, especially in north africa, you could say, is that somebody else's fault or is that a failure? >> with mally, we're talking about the next phase on the war on terror. this is the sahara desert. i don't know what she could have done to stop those, but in the other cases, we're in a better position with iran than we have ever been. we have a stronger international coalition. we're in a better place to make a deal. with north korea, no one has been able to stop north korea, but we're back in asia. we're back in asia in large part because she has been on a plane constantly back in the region making relationships. >> the middle east is very complicated, but one proxy americans look at when it comes
4:18 pm
to the middle east is israel, when it comes to dealing with iran, with israel, with the broader region. hillary clinton holds the record for the most countries visited at 112. israel, the least visits from any secretary of state since rogers. henry kissinger, 36 times for israel. is this significant? >> well, i mean, she was very energetic. i don't know if she gets frequent flyer miles for all of the miles she logged. >> sadly, no. that's probably the one perk she didn't get, right? >> right, but the fact is our relationship with israel hasn't been the best. s so i don't know if you can directly equate that. anne marie served in the administration. but under the obama administration, relations with israel have been very tough. they may have reached a bottom and mare they're on an uprise, but once again, i think this comes down to president obama's policy. remember, she's the secretary of state. she implements the president's agenda, and i think a lot of the
4:19 pm
problems out there, i think, were president obama's vision. i think i may be wrauk here, but i think secretary clinton would have done things a little different on some of these situations such as iran. in fact, i think she's s'more of the right on iran than president obama is. >> interesting point of view. a question, though, for you, about her popularity. that to me is what seems to be the most amazing thing. how has she achieved that to be so popular? i ask you that because you know her and you worked for her. early on in her campaign, people saw her at shrill and over the top, and now she's the beloved lady. >> i think people saw what she said in her campaign, is that she gets up every single morning and figures out how can she work her absolute hardest to advance the interests of the american people and frankly of people all over the world, and i think people have seen that. day in and day out. they have seen her exhausted, they have seen her injured, they have seen her get up and get back in the saddle and work
4:20 pm
incredibly hard. and she has done a superb job. >> thanks very much to both of you. we appreciate it, and our viewers, please let us know what you think of hillary clinton and will she be running for president in 2016. that's on we argue why the nomination should be hers. "outfront" next, seven years after falling into a coma, scientists in israel make a startling discovery about ariel sharon. plus, the policy for enforcing gun laws has been ineffective, and a lot of people have blamed the nra for it. we investigated, and that doesn't add up. and the x-factor. if there was a pill to help protect your eye health as you age... would you take it? well, there is. [ male announcer ] it's called ocuvite.
4:21 pm
a vitamin totally dedicated to your eyes, from the eye care experts at bausch + lomb. as you age, eyes can lose vital nutrients. ocuvite helps replenish key eye nutrients. ocuvite has a unique formula not found in your multivitamin to help protect your eye health. now that's a pill worth taking. [ male announcer ] ocuvite. help protect your eye health.
4:22 pm
woman: what do you mean, homeowners insurance doesn't cover floods? [ heart rate increases ] man: a few inches of water caused all this? [ heart rate increases ] woman #2: but i don't even live near the water. what you don't know about flood insurance may shock you -- including the fact that a preferred risk policy starts as low as $129 a year.
4:23 pm
for an agent, call the number that appears on your screen.
4:24 pm
our third story "outfront," lack of leadership. so the agency responsible for enforcing america's gun laws has been without a permanent director for six years. it's stunning and it's offensive, but it's not that attempts haven't been made. up until now though, every nominee has been blocked. who is to blame? some say the nra. here is joe johns with the investigation. >> since congress hasn't confirms a director of the bu
4:25 pm
bureau of alcohol, tobacco, and firearms for six years, they should confirm todd jones. >> the president's latest attempt to get a director confirmed for the atf is something congress has never done. gun control advocates are quick to point fingers. >> the mra through members of congress have sought to either defund or in some instances emasculate the atfe by restricting their operations in some ways as to prevent them from doing their job. >> the washington post editorial board said the gun rights lobby has spent considerable time and energy in pursuit of one goal, crippling the atf. the nra has been highly critical of the agency, which sees its mission as preventing violent crime by enforcing federal gun laws and tracing firearms used in crimes. but blaming the nra, does it add up? not exactly. in 2006, republicans in the
4:26 pm
congress required senate confirmation for the atf director. before that, the president could appoint anyone he wanted. so when president george w. bush nominated michael sullivan, it looked like an easy path, but he couldn't get a vote in a republican-controlled senate. >> did i ever think for a moment my nomination would be held up by a senator from idaho as related to one firearm licensed dealer? no. i didn't. >> idaho senator larry craig along with two other republican, all staunch supporters of the nra, held up sullivan's nomination, but it wasn't the nra's hands at work. it was about one local idaho gun seller's dispute with the atf. even silver himself said the nra didn't derail him. >> i didn't get any sense at all that the industry was opposed to my nomination. nor even the nra. >> when president obama took office, the senate just sat on
4:27 pm
his first nominee, andrew traver, even conservatives like house republican darrell issa called for action. >> andrew traver, who i believe is the 2010, november 2010 dezinate, should in fact be given an up or down vote. should in fact be given an opportunity to be confirmed. >> but republicans and the nra could spell trouble for todd jones. already senator chuck grassley is raising questions about his ties to the fast and furious scandal. the nra hasn't weighed in on jones yet, but nra president david keen does believe the atf deserves a permanent leader. >> should there be a bureau? >> of course. >> and a drether? >> of course. >> the issue has been about getting the right person in the job permanently. in the meantime, current nominee todd jones continues to serve as acting director of atf while also serving as the united states attorney in minnesota. his office didn't respond to cnn's request for comment.
4:28 pm
erin? >> pretty amazing story there. thanks to you, joe. we go this long and we talk about all of these new laws, we have to make sure what we have is working right. still to come, a catholic hospital says life begins at birth, and now colorado lawmakers are forced to decide when life really begins. we bring you this story as part of an ongoing "outfront" investigation. plus, president obama tells a reporter he goes skeet shooting all the time. really? and later in the show, iran launches its first manned spaceship, but you know, well, aren't they people, too? massive. bayer aspirin was the first thing the emts gave me. now, i'm on a bayer aspirin regimen. [ male announcer ] be sure to talk to your doctor before you begin an aspirin regimen. [ woman ] learn from my story. before you begin an aspirin regimen. i have obligations. cute tobligations, but obligations.g. i need to rethink the core of my portfolio.
4:29 pm
what i really need is sleep. introducing the ishares core, building blocks for the heart of your portfolio. find out why 9 out of 10 large professional investors choose ishares for their etfs. ishares by blackrock. call 1-800-ishares for a prospectus which includes investment objectives, risks, charges and expenses. read and consider it carefully before investing. risk includes possible loss of principal. when the doctor told me that i could smoke for the first week... i'm like...yeah, ok... little did i know that one week later i wasn't smoking. [ male announcer ] along with support, chantix is proven to help people quit smoking. it reduces the urge to smoke. some people had changes in behavior, thinking or mood, hostility, agitation, depressed mood and suicidal thoughts or actions while taking or after stopping chantix. if you notice any of these stop taking chantix and call your doctor right away. tell your doctor about any history of depression or other mental health problems, which could get worse while taking chantix. don't take chantix if you've had a serious allergic or skin reaction to it. if you develop these stop taking chantix and see your doctor right away as some can be life-threatening.
4:30 pm
if you have a history of heart or blood vessel problems, tell your doctor if you have new or worse symptoms. get medical help right away if you have symptoms of a heart attack. use caution when driving or operating machinery. common side effects include nausea, trouble sleeping and unusual dreams. it helps to have people around you... they say, you're much bigger than this. and you are. [ male announcer ] ask your doctor if chantix is right for you.
4:31 pm
4:32 pm
welcome back to the second half of "outfront." we start with stories we care about where we focus on reporting from the front lines and we begin in mally. french president fran swau hollande refused to speculate on how long france would continue to intervene. today, a spokesman said they don't want a conflict with french forces, but they will fight the malian army as soon as
4:33 pm
al qaeda linked extremists are pushed out of the nation. that's what they tell us. and meanwhile, in timbuktu, revels have razed the library that hold many books from preclonical africa. there were multiple reports of that today. >> yahoo reported quarterly results. we have been telling you about the company's ceo marissa mayer. one of the things she was hired to do was increase revenue. she's only had really five, i would say four months at the end of the year, but you know what? she actually delivered. yahoo showed annual revenue growth for the first time in four years. they were up 2%. that's still up. on the company's conference call, she describes yahoo's turn around as a multiyear march toward growth. >> and now, check this out, the best tricks competition at the winter x games. during the snow mobile finals,
4:34 pm
the finalist attempted this move unsuccessfully. oh, my god. his snow mobile kept going, crashed into a frens and went into the yocrowd. according to espn, one fan was injured, just injured. he was attended to and later released. oh, he later tweeted this photo. he flew through the air and he looked like he died, and he's out tweeting, so he's okay. he said, wishing my sled still looks like this. so glad it didn't hurt anyone when it flew into the groucrowd. >> it has been 543 days since the u.s. lost its top credit crea rating. what are we doing to get it back? the number fell because of limited supply. that's because there are shortages in some places. buyers are waiting. there has been a comeback in the housing market. now, our fourth story, defining when life begins. it's a controversial issue that came to a head in colorado today
4:35 pm
at the legislature. it was fueled in part by a story we brought you on friday. jeremy's wife laurie died of cardiac arrest in 2006. while 28 weeks pregnant with twins. the twins also died. jeremy filed a wrongful death lawsuit against the hospital where she died, but they said under colorado law, an unborn fetus is not considered a person. this is becoming an issue of national focus in colorado, and they were going to go ahead with legislation possibly today that would have redefined when life begins. what happened with that legislation? >> it's a bill that died in committee, and the supporter of it said it's very fortunate. that bill would have expanded the definition of fetal homicide in the state of colorado. and it was something that supporters really backed. they were spending the day on the steps of the
4:36 pm
legislature, and they were citing jeremy, his case is in the civil arena, but the questions are essentially the same. when does life begin? how does the state define it? how does the catholic church define it? and is the church being consistent? >> there's only one date on the grave site. >> yeah. that was the day they passed. >> a day that jeremy's twin boys never saw outside their mother's womb. they were at 28 weeks, viable, but died in the emergency room at st. thomas more hospital in canyon city, colorado. 31-year-old laurie seven months pregnant, died after a massive heart attack from a pulmonary emboli embolism. >> my heart breaks. >> he fired a wrongful death lawsuit against the hospital for his wife and boys.
4:37 pm
the cathlish healthnishatives mounted a stunning defense that contradicts the catholic church's teachings that life begins at conception. they said, to be a person, one must at some point have been born alive. >> i would find that hypocritical anywhere. there wasn't one person who went into that e.r. there were three. >> the archdiocese of denver said they would not comment on ongoing disputes but appeared to back pedal from the hospital's stance saying we will undertake a full review of this litigation and as the policies of catholic health initiatives to insure fidelity to the teaching of the catholic church. >> in the meantime, stodgehill is now bankrupt after being socked with the legal fees of the hospital. he won't give up. he want the state's highest court to weigh in on his case. he's appealing to the colorado supreme court, asking them if his sons were people under state
4:38 pm
law. >> the pain never goes away. you always love them. >> heather was at the capital in denver today where she fought for a law to insure that all unborn victims of homicide were considered people. for heather, this story is deeply personal. she was just days away from giving birth to a boy last july when she was hit by a drunk driver. she lost the baby, and state law prevented authorities from charging the driver with her unborn baby's death. >> it was really hard because someone took him from me. and it's really hard. the law says that brady wasn't a person. brady was 8 pounds 2 ounces. brady was a person. his life was worth defending. >> the pro life organization personalhood colorado helped heather launch a campaign to tell her story. heather is "outfront" tonight, joined by her mother who was
4:39 pm
also in the car for that horrific accident. heather, i just have to say, talking about your story, it's hard to comprehend, even think about comprehending what you went through. how has it been every day since then? i mean, those are the last few days where you were probably full of excitement, right? about meeting him. >> yeah. i was super excited. just leaving the doctor's office, being able to hear his heart beat and see the ultra sound pictures and everything of him. i was super excited, and then, you know, within a couple hours after the doctor's appointment, he was there, and then he was gone when i woke up in the icu, and that was horrible. it was an absolute horrible experience, and so now my mom and i are just trying to push forward and to just use our story and use brady as a way to get some recognition that this goes on a lot, and that we need to do something about it. >> and terry, you lost your
4:40 pm
grandson in this accident, and you were in the car, i know, with your daughter that day. what has been the hardest part for youo or what was the hardes part for you going through this, seeing your daughter lose her son? >> i truly believe is that one of the worst things is that when we told chargecouras were broug against the driver, none of them were counted against brady. it was like brady didn't matter, didn't count. that has been hard to deal with. >> health, i know that's why you're working with personhood colorado, and trying to change the law in colorado so that life will be defined to begin at conception in terms of defining a person so this can't happen again. today, though, obviously, the bill that was going to do just that was shot down. it didn't get through committee. are you going to keep fighting? >> oh, yes. we are not -- my mom and i, both have teamed up with personhood, and we're not going to stop this
4:41 pm
fight until we get this job done. >> personhood colorado describes itself as a pro life organization. its goal is to ban abortions. is that something that you both want? >> yes. we both are going to fight for that as well. and we're just going to start taking little steps at a time to get completely through all of the steps we need to take to get this all done with, to get the abortion done, taken care of, and get it the way it's supposed to be. >> heather and terry, thank you both very much for sharing your story with us. >> thank you so much. >> thank you. >> i want to bring in cnn's legal contributor, paul cowin, who is an attorney who defends doctors in malpractice cases. this is obviously a very tough issue. the personal stories are incredibly tragic, but obviously, if you define personhood beginning at conception, that would have questions in the abortion
4:42 pm
debate? >> those two define themselves as pro choice. we have been fearful that if we say a fetus is a person for the purpose of the law, criminal law or civil law, how can you allow this person to be aborted without a hearing? so there's a problem there in terms of the logic of it that disturbs people. >> and one thing, i mean, without getting into the whole nitty-gritty of the abortion debate. to me, if the person -- that baby when he died was 8 pounds 2 ounces, he was going to be born in a couple days. how can you not define that as a person? he was a viable life. >> i think most state legislatures would agree with you. that's why in most states, viability of the fetus is the area where they start to view a fea fetus as human under criminal law, and this sort of action in another state would be involuntary manslaughter and a very, very different kind of set of charges. >> they're going to push ahead with this. they're going to try to get this amendment into another bill. they're going to keep pushing.
4:43 pm
what is the likelihood that this pushes in colorado and becomes a national example that others follow? >> this is a poster child for the case. but colorado is such a strange state that legalized marijuana, but on the other hand, on this side of the ledger, they won't go along with any sort of severe penalties for drunken driving or if somebody even dies in a drunken driving accident. radically different from the rest of the country. i find it hard to predict what they'll do. >> paul, thank you very much. this will have implications around this nation. ahead, the president. so he said he goes skeet shooting all the time. is that add up? and iran's first astronaut launched into space. are they serious or just, you know, monkeying around? i'm up next, but now i'm singing the heartburn blues. hold on, prilosec isn't for fast relief. cue up alka-seltzer. it stops heartburn fast. ♪ oh what a relief it is!
4:44 pm
cue up alka-seltzer. it stops heartburn fast. i've got two tickets to paradise!l set? pack your bags, we'll leave tonight. uhh, it's next month, actually... eddie continues singing: to tickets to... paradiiiiiise! no four. remember? whoooa whooaa whooo! you know ronny, folks who save hundreds of dollars by switching to geico sure are happy. and how happy are they jimmy? happier than eddie money running a travel agency. get happy. get geico. fifteen minutes could save you fifteen percent or more. [ male announcer ] how could switchgrass in argentina,
4:45 pm
change engineering in dubai, aluminum production in south africa, and the aerospace industry in the u.s.? at t. rowe price, we understand the connections of a complex, global economy. it's just one reason over 75% of our mutual funds beat their 10-year lipper average. t. rowe price. invest with confidence. request a prospectus or summary prospectus with investment information, risks, fees and expenses to read and consider carefully before investing. with investment information, risks, fees and expenses ♪ (train horn) vo: wherever our trains go, the economy comes to life. norfolk southern. one line, infinite possibilities.
4:46 pm
olaf gets great rewards for his small business! pizza! [ garth ] olaf's small business earns 2% cash back on every purchase, every day! helium delivery. put it on my spark card! [ pop! ] [ garth ] why settle for less? great businesses deserve great rewards! awesome!!! [ male announcer ] the spark business card from capital one. choose unlimited rewards with 2% cash back or double miles on every purchase, every day! what's in your wallet? or double miles on every purchase, every day! see lioutdoors, or in.ight. transitions® lenses automatically filter just the right amount of light. so you see everything the way it's meant to be seen. maybe even a little better. visit your eyecare professional today to ask about our newest lenses, transitions vantage and transitions xtractive lenses. experience life well lit. ask which transitions adaptive lens is best for you. your doctor will say get smart about your weight.
4:47 pm
that's why there's glucerna hunger smart shakes. they have carb steady, with carbs that digest slowly to help minimize blood sugar spikes. [ male announcer ] glucerna hunger smart. a smart way to help manage hunger and diabetes. we're back with tonight's outer circle where we reach out to our sources around the world, and tonight we go to iran where the government said it launched a monkey into orbit and brought it back to earth. we're reporting for cairo, and i asked why iran would send a monkey into orbit. >> late night comedy shows are probably going to have a field day with this, but for iran, launching a monkey into space is serious business. eventually, they want to get a
4:48 pm
human being up there. they're starting with a monkey. before you make fun, remember, the u.s. did this in the 1950s as part of their space program. iran first tried this in 2011. it didn't work. state media reporting it worked this time around. this monkey was strapped in like a money making monkey business. very, very difficult, not clear when this happened. wherever iran tests any rocket, washington always sounds the alarnl, saying it could be a secret test for their nuclear program. it's very likely you'll hear some of those concerns again. >> thank you very much. now our fifth story "outfront," obama the skeet shooter. i'm not making this up. in an interview with the new york republic, the president revealed he can relate to people who enjoy firing guns. when asked if he has ever fired one, he replied, quote, yes, in fact at camp david, we do skeet
4:49 pm
shooting all the time. the reporter asked, the whole family, not the girls, but oftentimes guest of mine go up there, and i have a profound respect for hunting and i think those who dismiss that are making a big mistake. don't expect to see pictures of the president shooting skeet anytime soon. >> how often does the president go skeet shooting and there are photographs of him doing so? >> i would refer you simply to his comments. i don't know how often he does go to camp david with some regularity, but i'm not sure how often he's done that. >> is there a photograph of him doing that? >> maybe, but i haven't seen it. >> why haven't we heard about it before? >> because when he goes to camp david, he goes to spend time with his family and friends and relax, not to produce photo ops. >> we have heard about a lot of recreational activities at camp david. out front tonight, david, roland, and marsha blackburn. good to see all of you. all right, roland, there is some
4:50 pm
skepticism among conservatives and nonconservatives about the president's frequency of scoot sho skeet shooting. mark miller told us he's heard of bowling, golfer,an archery, t not skeet shooting. if you're going to say you do it all the time, don't you have to prove it? >> no, we went through four years of this man trying to prove he's an american. trying to prove he's a christian. i don't need a photo of his birth stroicertificate, so seri, and i don't care. he doesn't need to show a photo saying oh, there's a president holding a gun because i always thought it was stupid when a politician would have a photo of them wading through the weeds to show everybody, hey, he's a hunter. it's not that big of a deal and it's not going to change anybody's mind as relates to gun control in this country. >> that is true. if that's why he said it, i will
4:51 pm
think everyone will agree with you. representative blackburn, do you think this is not a relevant point of conversation? >> i think it is a relevant point of conversation. if he is a skeet shooter, why have we not heard of this, why have we not seen photos, why hasn't he referenced this at any point in time? we had this debate that is ongoing. you would have thought it would have been a point of reference. i tell you what i do think. i think he should invite me to camp david and i'll go skeet shooting with him and i'll beat him. >> i have been trying to go golfing with him. >> i said i was willing to go, and i'll challenge him to some skeet shooting. it's a great hobby, and i would hope that the president does enjoy it. >> david -- >> i challenged him. we'll see. >> let me ask you, because there's something about this, as to why the president would say this right now. whether it's true or not true, you know, president clinton
4:52 pm
tried to get democrats in line recently on this issue. he said to donors in aprie priv meeting, the passionate supporters of your opponents by looking down your nose at them. that brought to mind the now infamous comment by then candidate obama when he talked about people clinging to guns and religion. >> first, as someone who has missed more clay pigeons than -- >> i never hit one and i only went once. >> i can well imagine why the president wouldn't want photographers there. i wouldn't want them either. i think the president is in this case shooting at the wrong target. the thing that drives the gun debate in this country, really, it's not about hunting. hunting is a dwintalling activity. at this point, only 5% of americans even get hunting licenses. what drives the gun debate is fear of crime. what americans need to know if they're going to think intelligently about the use of weapons is how much crime has
4:53 pm
declined in this country over the past 20 years. people don't, i think, appreciate the magnitude of this and if you look at statistics today, americans are safer from crime than ever before, since good records began, and probably ever before in the entire history of the republic. if people knew that, that would have an impact. they do not need firearms to protect themselves. they are safer than ever before. that's the point to drive home. meanwhile, they are risking accidents, risking suicide among their loved ones. that's what debate is about. >> they take away we're safer than we have ever been before, we don't need firearms, and somebody like you might say we don't need to pass more gun control legislation. >> we don't need to pass more legislation, and the assault weapons ban didn't work. that's why it wasn't extended in 2004. and what individuals want is their freedom. they want the second amendment respected.
4:54 pm
and they want to make certain that we understand that. >> assault weapons ban, putting that aside for a moment, and the number, 2% to 8% happens on the assault weapons ban. it's not the number one culprit. handguns are. but would you support universal background checks? any change at all? >> the only time a background check does not happen is when an individual transfers to another individual. >> gun shows. family. >> most people at the gun shows, though, are licensed dealers and they are going through a background check. so the background checks, those work, and they root out people. what i want to see is when you find someone, a felon, who has tried to buy a gun, i want to see that person prosecuted. and i want to see the laws that we have on the books followed. >> roland, when you hear representative blackburn, do you think we're not going to get anywhere with an assault weapons ban or any sort of other
4:55 pm
legislati legislation? >> what i hear is someone who refuses to budge an inch. again, how hard is it to say, sure, why can't we have universal background checks? even if you're selling the weapon to a family member or someone else, why can't you still do that? and so that should be a straightforward easy answer, but if you're unwilling to budge, and look, i get tennessee, georgia, i'm fraught texas, but my goodness, even universal background checks, how hard is that? >> in a word. >> background checks are important, and we also need to make certain that we are checking mental health. >> i agree. >> but you would support a universal background check? >> sure. >> thank you very much. next, former israeli prime minister ariel sharon has been in a vegetative state, but in the past few days, scientists have made a totally shocking discovery. ...$10 off any turbo tax
4:56 pm
deluxe level software or higher! find thousands of big deals now... officemax.
4:57 pm
pretty sweet, huh? cute. but don't you have any apps on your phone that can make your life easier? who do you think i am, quicken loans? at quicken loans, we'll provide you with myql mobile. this amazingly useful app allows you to take pictures of your mortgage documents using an iphone or android smart phone... so you can easily send them to us. one more way quicken loans is engineered to amaze. ooh, la-la!
4:58 pm
4:59 pm
disc Borrow a DVD of this show
info Stream Only
Uploaded by
TV Archive
on 1/29/2013